Disability Attorney in Huntington, IN

Disability Lawyer in Huntington, Indiana

Being denied Social Security Disability benefits is frustrating, confusing, and far more common than most people realize. Many Huntington residents assume a denial means they are not eligible or that their condition is not serious enough. In reality, SSDI denials often have little to do with whether someone is truly disabled.

Call us at: 260-289-1528 today!

At Theisen Hubley Law, we help people in Huntington, Indiana who have been denied SSDI, are still waiting on a decision, or need help appealing a claim that stalled or failed. Disability law is one part of what we do. We also handle workers’ compensation, employment law, and personal injury under one roof, which matters more than most people expect when disability benefits are on the line.

SSDI Denials Are Common — Even for Legitimate Claims

A large percentage of SSDI applications are denied at the initial stage. Many estimates place first-time denial rates well over half of all claims. This does not mean the applicant did something wrong. It often means the Social Security Administration did not have enough information in the right format to approve the claim.

Some people are denied SSDI after a non-medical review. Others are denied even though their doctors clearly document limitations. Paperwork issues, work credit calculations, income thresholds, and incomplete medical records frequently lead to denied SSDI claims. A denial is not a final answer. It is often the beginning of the appeal process.

When SSI Is Denied but SSDI Is Still Pending — or Approved

It is common for people to receive mixed decisions. Some are denied SSI but approved SSDI. Others see SSI denied while SSDI remains pending. These outcomes happen because SSI and SSDI are different programs with different eligibility rules.

SSI focuses heavily on income and assets. SSDI focuses on work history and disability status. Understanding why one program was denied while another continues requires careful review. This is one area where many people lose benefits simply because they do not know how to respond correctly.

What Happens After an SSDI Denial

After an SSDI denial, you generally have the right to appeal. Many people successfully apply for SSDI after being denied, but the appeal must be handled properly and on time. Appeals are not just re-submissions. They require stronger evidence, clearer explanations, and a better understanding of how Social Security evaluates disability.

Waiting too long or submitting incomplete information can permanently damage a claim. This is why many people seek legal help after a denial rather than starting over alone.

Do You Need a Lawyer to Apply for SSDI?

Some people apply for SSDI without a lawyer and are approved. Many more are denied. Legal help becomes especially important when:

• Your SSDI claim has been denied
• Your medical records are incomplete or unclear
• You were injured at work
• You have an open workers’ compensation claim
• Employment issues affect your work history
• You are dealing with multiple legal issues at once

Disability claims rarely exist in isolation. They often overlap with work injuries, job loss, and income disputes.

One Firm for SSDI, Workers’ Compensation, Employment Law, and Injury Claims

This is where Theisen Hubley Law is different.

Many disabled workers are forced to juggle multiple law firms — one for SSDI, one for workers’ compensation, and another for employment or injury issues. That separation often leads to conflicting strategies, missed deadlines, or reduced benefits.

Our firm handles SSDI, workers’ compensation, employment law, and personal injury under one roof. This allows us to coordinate your claims instead of letting one case undermine another.

If your disability began with a workplace injury, we can address both your disability claim and your workers’ compensation case using a unified strategy.

(See our Workers’ Compensation FAQ for more information on how these claims interact.)

Medical Evidence Matters — and Gaps Hurt Claims

Social Security disability decisions rely heavily on medical documentation. Many treating doctors do not structure records in a way that meets Social Security standards. As a result, valid claims are denied due to missing or unclear evidence.

Theisen Hubley Law works with medical professionals for examinations and evaluations when appropriate. This helps clarify limitations, address inconsistencies, and strengthen appeal records without relying solely on incomplete charts or rushed office notes.

How Theisen Hubley Law Helps Disabled Workers in Huntington

We help clients who are:

• Dealing with denied SSDI claims
• Still waiting after months with no decision
• Unsure whether to appeal or reapply
• Balancing SSDI with workers’ compensation or employment disputes

We serve clients throughout Indiana, including Huntington, and offer remote consultations when mobility or health makes travel difficult. Our goal is clarity, coordination, and realistic guidance — not pressure.

Get Answers Before Giving Up on Your Claim

A denied SSDI claim does not mean you are out of options. It means your claim needs a stronger strategy.

If you live in Huntington, Indiana and need help with SSDI, workers’ compensation, employment law, or injury-related disability issues, contact Theisen Hubley Law to discuss your situation and understand your next steps.

Two Attorneys on Every Case:

At Theisen Hubley Law, we provide a personalized approach to your disability case. That's why we have two experienced attorneys working on every Social Security Disability case. At the onset, Attorney Christina Hubley works directly with you, helping you through the consultation and initial stages of the disability claim. If your case goes to court, we make sure we get you the best possible outcome by having Attorney Nathaniel Hubley help coordinate strategy leading up to court so you have two attorneys making sure we do everything possible to get you the best possible outcome. This ensures that your case is thoroughly managed from start to finish by two licensed and experienced attorneys. Looking to hire a law firm to handle your disability case? Ask them if they’ll have two disability attorneys working together on your case. No other law firm in Northeast Indiana has a team of attorneys working together on each case to help get you the best possible outcome.

“Need legal advice? We’re here to help. We offer free consultations for Workers' Compensation, Personal Injury, and Social Security Disability cases. Due to high demand, we require a $300 pre-payment for employment law consultations, which you can conveniently pay through our secure online portal.”